As an Etsy seller, I understand the importance of finding the best print-on-demand service to create and sell my products. Two of the most popular options are Printful and Printify. Both services offer a wide range of products, high-quality printing, and reliable shipping. However, choosing the right one for your business can be a challenging decision.
In this article, I will run through the pros and cons of each provider and work out which is the best to use for you.
Overview of Printful and Printify
What is Printful?
Printful is a print-on-demand dropshipping service that offers a wide range of products for customization, including t-shirts, hoodies, hats, and more. Printful integrates with several e-commerce platforms, including Etsy, and handles the printing, packaging, and shipping of orders for its customers.
What is Printify?
Printify is another print-on-demand dropshipping service that offers a variety of products for customization, such as t-shirts, mugs, and phone cases. Printify also integrates with several e-commerce platforms, including Etsy, and provides printing, packaging, and shipping services for its customers.
Features and Benefits of Printful
Printful offers several features and benefits to its customers, including:
- A wide range of products for customization, including clothing, accessories, and home decor items.
- High-quality printing technology that ensures that designs look great on products.
- Integration with several e-commerce platforms, including Etsy, making it easy to set up a shop and start selling.
- Automated order fulfillment, which means that Printful handles the printing, packaging, and shipping of orders.
- Excellent customer service, with a dedicated support team available to answer questions and resolve issues.
Features and Benefits of Printify
Printify also offers several features and benefits to its customers, including:
- A variety of products for customization, including clothing, accessories, and home decor items.
- Integration with several e-commerce platforms, including Etsy, making it easy to set up a shop and start selling.
- Printing, packaging, and shipping services that are handled by Printify, so customers don’t have to worry about these tasks.
- An easy-to-use design tool that allows customers to create and customize their products.
- A competitive pricing structure that allows customers to maximize their profits.
Integration with Etsy
How to Integrate Printful with Etsy
Integrating Printful with Etsy is a straightforward process. First, you need to create a Printful account, then connect it to your Etsy store. Once connected, you can start uploading your designs to Printful and adding them to your Etsy shop. Printful will take care of printing and shipping your products to your customers.
How to Integrate Printify with Etsy
Integrating Printify with Etsy is also a simple process. First, you need to create a Printify account, then connect it to your Etsy store. Once connected, you can start creating your products on Printify and adding them to your Etsy shop. Printify will handle the production and shipping of your products.
Pros and Cons of Using Printful with Etsy
Using Printful with Etsy has its advantages and disadvantages. One of the main advantages is the quality of the products and the printing. Printful uses high-quality materials and printing techniques, which results in excellent products. Another advantage is the integration with Etsy, which makes it easy to manage your products and orders. However, the prices of the products are higher compared to other print-on-demand services, which can affect your profit margins.
Pros and Cons of Using Printify with Etsy
Using Printify with Etsy also has its pros and cons. One of the main advantages is the wide range of products available on Printify. You can choose from over 300 products, including apparel, home decor, and accessories. Another advantage is the competitive pricing, which can help you increase your profit margins. However, the quality of the products and printing is not as high as Printful’s, which can affect customer satisfaction. Overall, both Printful and Printify are excellent options for selling on Etsy. It ultimately comes down to your personal preferences and business needs.
Product Catalog and Pricing
Product Catalog of Printful
As a print-on-demand service, Printful offers a wide variety of products that can be customized with designs, including apparel, accessories, home decor, and more. Some of the most popular items in their product catalog include t-shirts, hoodies, and phone cases. Printful also offers a range of eco-friendly options, such as organic cotton t-shirts and recycled polyester products.
Product Catalog of Printify
Similar to Printful, Printify offers a diverse range of products that can be customized with designs, including apparel, accessories, and home decor. Some of the most popular items in their product catalog include t-shirts, mugs, and canvas prints. Printify also offers a range of products from trusted brands like Gildan and Bella+Canvas.
Pricing of Printful
Printful’s pricing varies based on the product being customized, but they do offer a helpful pricing calculator on their website that allows users to estimate costs. Generally, Printful’s prices are slightly higher than some of its competitors, but they do offer a high level of quality and a wide range of customization options.
Pricing of Printify
Printify’s pricing also varies based on the product being customized, but they do offer a pricing chart on their website that outlines costs for each product. Overall, Printify’s prices tend to be slightly lower than Printful’s, making them a more budget-friendly option for some sellers. In terms of product catalog and pricing, both Printful and Printify offer a wide range of products that can be customized with designs, and their pricing varies based on the product being customized. Ultimately, the best choice for a seller will depend on their specific needs and budget.
There is also the option to upgrade to Prinify Premium for extra savings
Order Fulfillment and Shipping
Order Fulfillment Process of Printful
As an Etsy seller, I appreciate the ease of use of Printful’s order fulfillment process. Once I receive an order on Etsy, Printful automatically receives the order information and begins the fulfillment process. Printful’s API automates the order fulfillment process, which saves me time and effort. Printful’s team of experts handles the printing, packing, and shipping of my products, which ensures that my customers receive high-quality products.
Order Fulfillment Process of Printify
Printify’s order fulfillment process is also straightforward and easy to use. However, Printify doesn’t own the production process, nor do they print on the products. Instead, Printify partners with multiple print and fulfillment providers around the world. This means that the quality of the products may vary depending on the provider that I choose. I appreciate the flexibility that Printify offers, but it requires more effort on my part to ensure that my customers receive high-quality products.
Shipping Options of Printful
Printful offers a variety of shipping options to choose from, including standard, expedited, and express shipping. Printful’s shipping speeds are fast, and the shipping rates are affordable. I appreciate that Printful offers a global reach, which means that I can sell my products to customers all over the world.
Shipping Options of Printify
Printify’s shipping options are also flexible and affordable. However, Printify’s shipping speeds are slower than Printful’s, and the shipping rates may vary depending on the provider that I choose. Printify is almost exclusively focused on the US, which means that I may have limited options for shipping my products to customers outside of the US. Overall, both Printful and Printify offer easy-to-use order fulfillment processes and affordable shipping options. However, I prefer Printful’s automated order fulfillment process and faster shipping speeds.
Customer Support and Reviews
When it comes to choosing a print-on-demand service provider for your Etsy store, customer support and reviews are two important factors to consider. In this section, I will discuss the customer support and reviews of both Printful and Printify.
Customer Support of Printful
Printful has a dedicated customer support team that is available 24/7 to assist you with any questions or issues you may have. They offer support via email, phone, and live chat. In addition, they have a comprehensive knowledge base and a community forum where you can get help from other users.
Overall, customers have praised Printful’s customer support for being responsive, helpful, and knowledgeable. However, some users have reported long wait times on the phone and slow response times via email.
Customer Support of Printify
Printify also offers customer support via email and live chat, but they do not have a phone support option. They have a knowledge base and a community forum as well. However, their customer support team is not available 24/7 and their response times may vary.
Customers have mixed reviews about Printify’s customer support. Some users have reported quick and helpful responses, while others have complained about slow response times and unhelpful support.
Reviews of Printful
Printful has a strong reputation on review sites such as Trustpilot and Sitejabber. They have an average rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars on Trustpilot and 4.3 out of 5 stars on Sitejabber. Customers have praised their high-quality products, fast shipping, and easy-to-use platform. However, some users have reported issues with order fulfillment and print quality.
Get started with Printful here > PRINTFUL
Reviews of Printify
Printify also has a decent reputation on review sites. They have an average rating of 4.1 out of 5 stars on Trustpilot and 4.2 out of 5 stars on Sitejabber. Customers have praised their wide range of product options and competitive pricing. However, some users have reported issues with print quality and order fulfillment.
Get started with Printify here > PRINTIFY
Conclusion
After comparing Printful and Printify for Etsy, I have found that both platforms offer high-quality print-on-demand services with their own unique strengths and weaknesses.
Printful is known for its fast shipping speeds and global reach, making it a great option for sellers who prioritize quick turn-around times and worldwide shipping. However, their prices are generally higher than Printify’s.
On the other hand, Printify offers more affordable pricing and a wider range of product options, especially when it comes to clothing. However, their shipping speeds are generally slower than Printful’s and they have a more limited global reach.
Ultimately, the choice between Printful and Printify for Etsy comes down to personal preference and priorities. Sellers should consider factors such as shipping times, pricing, product options, and global reach when making their decision.
It’s also worth noting that both platforms offer straightforward integration with Etsy, making it easy for sellers to start selling their custom-made products on the platform.
We have more on this subject in this article > Printify vs. Printful: Which POD Service Offers the Best Value for Your Money?